
Earlier this week, thousands of people watched in horror as the famous Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris burned. In the aftermath, some have questioned why this building seems to matter more than other great losses around the world. I can’t say that this tragedy is worse than others, but this one strikes me more deeply. You see, I have a personal connection to the great cathedral.
I first saw Notre Dame in 1975. I was a wide-eyed, not quite starving student in Paris. Having come from California (where buildings were mostly short due to earthquakes), through rural Iowa (where there is not sufficient numbers of people to warrant tall buildings), I found Paris in general, and Notre Dame in particular, stunning–a place where history enveloped me and connected me to the people who lived there before.

Over the months I lived in Paris, I walked by Notre Dame almost daily since one of my classes was in a building alongside the cathedral. As I crossed the plaza and turned into the alley in bright sunshine, chilly sleet, or gloomy rain, the majesty and beauty of Notre Dame never ceased to amaze. The gargoyles, statues, and carvings all told stories with enough detail to keep me entranced. I felt transported to the middle ages, when the cathedral was built and presented the Bible in stone to all who passed.
The cathedral was built over a span of some 200 years, starting in 1163, during the reign of Louis VII. The first mass was celebrated at the newly consecrated high altar almost twenty years later. Over the reigns of several monarchs and many different builders, the cathedral was finally finished in 1345.

Monday’s fire was not the first time Notre Dame faced destruction. In 1548, a group of French Huguenots stormed the church and destroyed statues they felt were idolatrous. Almost 200 years later, more damage was done by over enthusiastic ‘renovations,’ in an effort to make the church building more classical, in line with the then current fashion.. Many of the stained glass windows from the middle ages were replaced with clear glass to let in more light. The spire was damaged by wind and removed near the end of the 18th century. Further damage was done during the French Revolution, when the cathedral was seen as a celebration of the French monarchy. Many statues were pulled down and beheaded in violent protest to the wealth and power of the nobles.
Some restoration of the great cathedral began in 1801, under Napoleon’s government. Further interest in restoring Notre Dame was sparked by Victor Hugo’s immensely popular novel, The Hunchback of Notre Dame. For twenty-five years, beginning in the middle of the 19th century, the cathedral underwent massive restoration, including a new spire.

In the 20th century, stonework of the cathedral was cleaned, removing years of soot and grime caused by air pollution. Once again, people could see the stories in the stone. One such story that intrigued me was that of St. Denis. He was the first bishop of Paris. The local people and their Romans rulers objected to his preaching Christianity. He was beheaded in 258 on the hill of Mont Martre. The legend says that he picked up his head and carried it six miles to the place he would be buried (where the Basilica of St. Denis was later built.) Like the cathedral that sports his statue, St. Denis was truly resilient, beating the odds and leaving a lasting legacy.
Still, Monday’s fire is a reminder that nothing is permanent. Certain places become cultural symbols and we expect them to remain intact. But fires, earthquakes, tsunamis, and human folly have a way of destroying those hopes. The damage to Notre Dame is no greater, but also no less, than the loss of any great monument of human achievement. Whenever any such cultural icon is destroyed, all of us should weep. For within those cultural symbols lie the stories of all humanity.
Sources:
Fuentes, Jose Luís Corral. An 800-year history of Paris’s Notre Dame Cathedral. National Geographic History Magazine. May/June 2017, updated April 15, 2019
St. Denis.Encyclopedia Britanica. April 19, 2019. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Saint-Denis
As legends go, it’s a pretty weird one. The famous blarney stone is a large block of limestone set into the far wall of a machicolation high up in Blarney Castle. (A machicolation is a box-like, floorless opening in the battlements, used to pour hot oil or other nasty stuff on intruders.) They* say that if you climb to the top of the ruined keep of Blarney Castle, lay down and hang over the edge backwards far enough to kiss that block of limestone set into the battlements, you’ll be blessed with the gift of gab. You’ll be able to regale audiences with your silvered tongue and eloquence, with the fluency and perhaps even the loquacity to rival the best orators.

In past posts, I wrote of train wrecks and disasters, but in most cases, I really do find train travel relaxing. Lest anyone think badly of Scottish trains after my New Year’s day experience years ago, I can share a much better train ride. A few years ago, I returned to Scotland and rode the Jacobite steam train from Glenfinnan to Mallaig. Although Harry Potter and his friends faced the dementors on this train, I had no problems with the ride.









On a crisp fall day in 2018, Boston Common plays host to all sorts of people. Though the sky is overcast, tourists stroll along the winding paths pst the Frog Pond, Children play . and old men park on benches to read the newspaper. Along the north side of the park a musician strums his guitar, the open case in front of him inviting donations. In another corner, several dozen people gather for an ecumenical outdoor church service led by a woman with a microphone. In short, the oldest public park in America is the heart of Boston, providing a free, open, space for the people to use as they will, just as it has done for the last 384 years.









